People talk
Guestbook
“ Such a fun and welcoming spot! Mary Jane’s Dairy Bar has that classic ice cream stand charm with bright, cheerful window art and a family-friendly atmosphere. The staff is super friendly and keeps the line moving, even when it gets busy. They offer a great variety of ice cream flavors and fun treats for all ages. Twins loved it, and so did I! They each had chocolate ice scream sandwiches and I enjoyed a cookies and cream brownie fudge/caramel Sunday. Highly recommend trying the ice cream sandwiches or anything topped with whip cream and a cherry . We’ll definitely be back! ”
“ Friendly staff Great tasting ice cream. Got coffee and coconut flavor both were made very yum ”
“ The best place for Ice Cream in the Hudson Valley! Highly recommended if you’re looking for a quick treat! Prices are average but you get more than what you pay for! ”
“ Great selection of ice cream flavors and items. Can get crowded but things move. Have small area with pinic tables to sit at . Parking can be troublesome when busy ”
“ We drove about 30 minutes to try Mary Jane Dairy Bar, and overall it was a nice experience. The line wasn’t long, which was great, and there was plenty of parking, so it was easy to get in and out. They did accidentally make a mint chocolate chip shake when I had asked for cookie dough, but they quickly fixed it. The shake itself was very thick,more like ice cream in a cup..so it was tough to drink through the straw. On the bright side, the cotton candy ice cream was a huge hit with my younger son, and he really enjoyed it. All in all, it was worth the trip and I’d come back again. ”
Menu
Tropic Temptation
P'nut Butter
Chocolate
Strawberry
Banana
Story & Atmosphere
Mary Jane's Dairy Bar
Mary Jane's Dairy Bar, nestled in Newburgh, NY, offers a nostalgic retreat into classic American ice cream culture. Located at 5334 US-9W, this charming dairy bar combines bright, cheerful window artwork with a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere that immediately invites visitors to relax and indulge. From the moment you step up to the counter, the friendly staff ensures a swift and pleasant experience, even during busy times.
The true highlight of Mary Jane's is its diverse and delicious selection of ice cream flavors and treats. Whether you crave a thick, creamy shake or a traditional soft serve, the menu covers a wide range of favorites—from chocolate ice cream sandwiches to seasonal specialties and Italian ices. The quality is evident in every bite, satisfying both the young and the young at heart.
Customers consistently praise the welcoming vibe and attentive service, noting that while the place can get busy, the team handles crowds efficiently. The casual outdoor seating with picnic tables adds to the community feel, making it an ideal spot to savor a quick treat or gather with friends and family. Though parking can be tight during peak hours, the overall experience more than compensates.
Personally, the blend of classic charm and quality flavors makes Mary Jane's Dairy Bar a standout in the Hudson Valley. The ice cream’s rich texture and the variety available speak of care and passion behind the counter. It’s the perfect guilty pleasure after a long, warm day—comforting, simple, and thoroughly enjoyable. Whether you’re stopping by for a shake, an ice cream sandwich, or a scoop of cookie dough, Mary Jane’s delivers a memorable taste of Americana.
Easy Booking